Technology Services

Persuasive Web Design, Part 5: Beware of Offering Too Much Choice

It’s great to have choice. But as with so many other things, too much choice can be a bad thing.

In a study* conducted in 2000, customers at an upscale grocery store encountered a tasting booth displaying either 6 (limited choice) or 24 (extensive choice) different varieties of jams. Among other things, the following data were collected:

  • The percentage of passersby who approached the booth.
  • The percentage who actually made a purchase.

The results were astonishing. Although the booth with 24 varieties attracted more initial interest (60% of passersby approached the booth, as opposed to the 40% who approached the booth with 6 varieties) it was a dismal failure when it came to making sales.

We’re not talking a subtle difference. The booth offering 6 varieties converted at 30%; the booth offering 24 varieties converted at 3%. That’s right, limited choice outperformed extensive choice by a factor of ten.

So if you think you’re doing your customers (or yourself) a favor by presenting extensive options, think again. You might well be better off presenting only a handful of the best options. Too much choice can lead to decision paralysis.

*Iyengar, Sheena S. and Mark Lepper (2000). “When Choice is Demotivating: Can One Desire Too Much of a Good Thing?” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 76: 995-1006. https://www.columbia.edu/~ss957/whenchoice.html

Cardinal Path

Share
Published by
Cardinal Path

Recent Posts

Optimizing user experiences with Digital Experience Analytics (DXA) platforms

As consumers become increasingly digitally savvy, and more and more brand touchpoints take place online,…

1 month ago

Enabling Value-Based Bidding with Google Tightlock

Marketers are on a constant journey to optimize the efficiency of paid search advertising. In…

2 months ago

Resolving “Unassigned” Traffic in GA4

Unassigned traffic in Google Analytics 4 (GA4) can be frustrating for data analysts to deal…

2 months ago

This website uses cookies.